Select dates to see exact prices
Select dates to see exact prices
1 / 68
Good to know
Waterfront outdoor swimming pool
Relax by the scenic heated pool with attentive service, offering breathtaking views of Crescent Beach and the bay.
Upscale seafood dining with bay views
Savor delicious meals at the celebrated Terrace restaurant, featuring upscale seafood and American cuisine with stunning water vistas.
Full-service spa and wellness facilities
Unwind with a variety of treatments at the on-site spa, complete with a sauna and steam room for ultimate relaxation.
Direct Crescent Beach access
Enjoy immediate access to the protected waters and gentle breezes of Crescent Beach, perfect for swimming, paddleboarding, and kayaking.
Engaging family-friendly activities
Discover a wide range of seasonal activities for all ages, including volleyball, pickleball, pumpkin painting, outdoor movie nights, and s'mores.
Classic American resort experience
Experience a timeless stay at this historic 1927 resort, blending old-world charm with modern luxury, ideal for couples, friends, and families seeking a tranquil escape.
Historic cottages with modern comforts
Stay in one of 16 private cottages, offering country-style charm with amenities like kitchens or kitchenettes, fireplaces, and private decks.
This summary was created by AI and might not be 100% accurate.
Rooms
Hillside Room
- 1 1 King Bed
- Sleeps 2
- 215 sq ft
Terrace Room
- 1 1 King Bed
- Sleeps 2
- 230 sq ft
Corner Preferred Room
- 1 1 King Bed and 1 Double Sofa Bed
- Sleeps 4
- 230 sq ft
Room (Waterview)
- 1 1 King Bed
- Sleeps 2
- 215 sq ft
Reviews
Excellent
based on 520 ratings from top
sites
This rating is from the trivago Rating Index (tRI), which combines guest ratings from top sites for a trustworthy result.Learn how the tRI works
sites
Review summary
Summarized by AI from 400+ reviews
A serene waterfront escape for families and couples.
This historic property serves as a tranquil destination for families and couples seeking a refined coastal getaway. The resort sits alongside Shelter Island and is rounded out by recreational facilities that include a pristine pool and waterfront access. Guests frequently praise the well-appointed retreat provided by the elegant, comfortable rooms, and those looking for a standout dining experience should prioritize the popular Wednesday night BBQ.
Some guests mentioned: inconsistent service, thin walls, variable dining quality.
Rated above average for Shelter Island
Guest reviews
Excellent91%
Very good3%
Good0%
Fair0%
Poor6%
Top amenities
- WiFi in lobby
- WiFi in rooms
- Pool
- Spa
- Parking
- A/C
- Restaurant
- Hotel bar
- Gym
All amenities
Wellness
- Beauty salon
- Steam room
- Massage
- Sauna
Property amenities
- Business centre
- Arcade/Video games
- Lift
- Gym
Room amenities
- Openable windows
- Television
- Central heating
- Air conditioning
Sports facilities
- Pool table
- Bike rental
- Golf course
- Fitness
For children
- Kid meals
Location
Distance from The Pridwin Hotel
Greenport:3.5 km
Southold Historical Museum:4.4 km
Shelter Island:5.5 km
Custom House:10.3 km
Sag Harbor Whaling Museum:10.4 km
Bridgehampton Historical Museum:16 km
Water Mill Museum:17.9 km
Water Mill Windmill:17.9 km
Parrish Art Museum:18.4 km
Guild Hall:19.9 km
Mulford Farm Museum:19.9 km
Bradley International Airport:100 km
Explore nearby attractions
Property info
81 Shore Rd, Shelter Island, 11964, USAFrequently Asked Questions about The Pridwin Hotel
Is there a pool area at The Pridwin Hotel?
Yes, The Pridwin Hotel offers 2 pool areas.
Are pets allowed at The Pridwin Hotel?
No, The Pridwin Hotel doesn’t allow pets.
Is parking available at The Pridwin Hotel?
Yes, The Pridwin Hotel provides Parking for guests.
What time is check-in and check-out at The Pridwin Hotel?
Check-in at The Pridwin Hotel is available from: . Check-out time is by .
Where is The Pridwin Hotel located?
The Pridwin Hotel is located in 81 Shore Rd, 11964, Shelter Island, USA.
The prices and availability we receive from booking sites change constantly. This means you may not always find the exact same offer you saw on trivago when you land on the booking site.
Among Top Rated Hotels in Shelter Island
- Faraway Sag HarborSelect dates to see exact prices
- The Shoals Suites & SlipsSelect dates to see exact prices
- Silver Sands Motel & Beach BungalowsSelect dates to see exact prices
- Greenporter HotelSelect dates to see exact prices
- The MenhadenSelect dates to see exact prices
- EHP Resort & MarinaSelect dates to see exact prices
- The SagaponackSelect dates to see exact prices
- East Hampton House ResortSelect dates to see exact prices
- Topping Rose HouseSelect dates to see exact prices
