The Chequit
3 StarsOn-site dining with harbor views, Historic Victorian architecture and porch
Select dates to see exact prices
Hotels in Shelter Island (New York State, USA)
In order to supply this free comparison, booking sites pay us a fee when a user clicks on their specific offer. We do not display any offers (including cheaper offers) that do not meet our minimum fee requirements. Cheaper offers may on occasion be available under "More deals" as we request updated offers from online booking sites when you click that button. Learn how trivago works.
267 hotels in Shelter Island
Shelter Island House
4 StarsOn-site Chez Marie restaurant bar, Seasonal outdoor pool and garden
Select dates to see exact pricesThe Pridwin Hotel
4 StarsOn-site dining and weekly barbecue, Waterfront views on Crescent Beach
Select dates to see exact pricesAmerican Beech Hotel
4 StarsOn-Site Dining and Bars, Central Greenport Village Location
Select dates to see exact pricesWest Neck Guesthouse
4 StarsLoaner bikes and beach gear, Proximity to local island attractions
Select dates to see exact pricesSunset Beach
2 StarsSelect dates to see exact pricesHouse on Chase Creek
Walk to North Ferry and restaurants, Explore island with bike rentals
Select dates to see exact pricesSeven - a boutique B&B on Shelter Island
Heated pool and evening firepit, Seven-minute walk to Crescent Beach
Select dates to see exact pricesPrivate Hamptons Cottage
Select dates to see exact pricesCottage Fields Of Lavender By The Sea 5min Greenport Shelter Island
Select dates to see exact pricesModern Farmhouse W/ Salt Water Gunite Pool, Many Outdoor Spaces, And Fire Pit
Select dates to see exact pricesOne Bedroom Duplex Farmhouse
Select dates to see exact pricesSeven on Shelter Island
4 StarsSelect dates to see exact pricesVery Large, Comfortable, Victorian 4 Bedroom House + Beach Club
Select dates to see exact pricesWaterfront Charmer On Idyllic Shelter Island For Summer Rental
Select dates to see exact pricesShelter Island Waterfront Home
Select dates to see exact pricesShelter Island, Ny Fully Renovated Farmhouse With Heated Pool
Select dates to see exact pricesSummer Beach Paradise
Select dates to see exact prices3 Story Contemporary
Select dates to see exact pricesMint Condition Water Mill South Of The Highway With Mecox Bay Access
Select dates to see exact pricesUnbelievable Water Views, 50 Heated Pool And Private Beach
Select dates to see exact pricesBeautiful Shelter Island Getaway On Over An Acre, Minutes From The Ferry!
Select dates to see exact pricesCozy Greenport Cottage
Select dates to see exact pricesGreenport Village On The Bay
Select dates to see exact pricesTranquil 3br Shelter Island Beach House With Private Beach Access
Select dates to see exact pricesBeautiful Shelter Island/hamptons Beach House Monthly Rental
Select dates to see exact pricesSun-filled, Custom-designed 5-bedroom House In Sag Harbor W/ Heated Pool And Spa
Select dates to see exact pricesAia Award Winning Country Estate In Tranquil Shelter Island
Select dates to see exact pricesSummer In Style On Shelter Island - Modern House Only Available All Season
Select dates to see exact pricesThe Greenport Beach Cottage: 3 Min Walk To Beach, 3 Min Drive To Town
Select dates to see exact pricesSterling Harbor, Walking Distance To The Center: Spacious Studio For 4 People
Select dates to see exact pricesWaterfront Retreat With Heated Pool, Spa & Seasonal Water Sports
Select dates to see exact pricesChic Coastal Farmhouse With Private Pool, Steps From The Water Your...
Select dates to see exact pricesBreathtaking Waterfront 5-bedroom House In Charming Shelter Island With Pool
Select dates to see exact pricesSandpoint by Rove Travel - 6BR Family Home with Pool
Select dates to see exact prices
The prices and availability we receive from booking sites change constantly. This means you may not always find the exact same offer you saw on trivago when you land on the booking site.
